Greek Yogurt Ice Cream

Common Questions

Can you just freeze Greek yogurt to make frozen yogurt?

You can freeze Greek yogurt, but freezing it on its own won’t give you that soft, creamy frozen yogurt texture. Plain frozen Greek yogurt usually turns very firm and icy because it doesn’t have enough sugar or fat to keep it scoopable.
That’s why this recipe uses whole milk Greek yogurt, maple syrup, and vanilla extract. The maple syrup helps sweeten the yogurt and improves the texture, while the full-fat yogurt keeps it creamy and rich. It’s still a simple 3-ingredient frozen treat, but the result is so much better than freezing yogurt by itself!

What yogurt makes the best frozen yogurt?

Full-fat Greek yogurt makes the best homemade frozen yogurt. It has a thick, creamy texture and enough richness to help the frozen yogurt taste smooth instead of icy.
I recommend using a high-quality vanilla whole milk Greek yogurt for this recipe. Since there are only 3 ingredients, the flavor of the yogurt really matters! If you use nonfat or low-fat yogurt, it can still work, but the texture may be more icy and less creamy.

Why is my homemade frozen yogurt icy?

Homemade frozen yogurt can turn icy if the yogurt is too low in fat, there isn’t enough sweetener, or it freezes for too long without being mixed or spun. Greek yogurt has a lot of water content, so it needs a little help to become creamy once frozen.
For the best texture, use whole milk Greek yogurt, don’t skip the maple syrup, and let the frozen yogurt thaw for 15-20 minutes before scooping if you’re using the classic loaf pan method. If you’re using the Ninja Creami, spinning it after freezing helps make the texture extra creamy and scoopable!

What ingredients should not be in homemade frozen yogurt?

For the best homemade frozen yogurt, I try to keep the ingredients simple and avoid anything that doesn’t freeze well or changes the texture too much. Ingredients with a lot of extra water can make the frozen yogurt icy, while some mix-ins can become too hard once frozen.

I recommend avoiding:
– Watery fruit purees – These can make the frozen yogurt icy unless they’re cooked down or blended into a balanced recipe.
– Large fresh fruit pieces – They can freeze solid and be hard to bite into.
– Too many liquid add-ins – Extra milk, juice, or coffee can thin out the mixture and make it icier.
– Low-fat or nonfat yogurt – These can work, but they won’t be as creamy as whole milk Greek yogurt.

This Greek Yogurt Ice Cream recipe has been my go-to healthy frozen treat this summer! With only 3 ingredients and 15 grams of protein, I could not be more obsessed. It’s creamy, perfectly sweet, and SO easy to make! I love making it in my Ninja Creami for the creamiest texture, but it also works great made in a loaf pan or any airtight container. No blending required! Add any toppings you want for the BEST creamy yogurt ice cream.

Greek Yogurt Ice Cream Recipe

After my Cottage Cheese Ice Cream recipe went completely viral on Instagram (opens in a new tab) and TikTok, (opens in a new tab) I knew I had to make other healthy ice cream variations! And when it comes to high-protein ice cream options, Greek Yogurt is one of my go-to choices.

The key to making the BEST Greek Yogurt Ice Cream is to use a high-quality, full-fat Greek yogurt! I love to use vanilla flavored yogurt for an extra sweetness, but plain would work great as well. With just 3 ingredients, this simple recipe turns out perfectly every single time. Add a drizzle of peanut butter, chocolate chips, berries, or anything you want! It’s SO. GOOD.

Homemade Frozen Yogurt Ingredients

You’ll just need 3 simple ingredients to get started!

• Vanilla Whole Milk Greek Yogurt – The base of this recipe! Using whole milk yogurt gives it that rich, smooth texture. Feel free to use plain Greek yogurt if you want a little more control over the sweetness.
• Maple Syrup – Naturally sweetens the ice cream without refined sugar. Honey or agave syrup can also work here!
• Vanilla Extract – Adds depth and enhances that classic ice cream flavor. Vanilla paste (opens in a new tab) can give it an even stronger flavor!

TIP: Want to make it dairy-free? You can swap the Greek yogurt with a plant-based version like almond or coconut milk yogurt. Just note that the texture may be slightly softer!

How to Make Frozen Greek Yogurt Ice Cream

All you’ll need is a loaf pan and about 5 minutes to whisk the ingredients together. OR you can use a Ninja Creami (opens in a new tab) for even better results! Then freeze overnight and it’s ready to go. Here’s how to make Greek Yogurt Ice Cream:

1. Mix It Up – Whisk together the yogurt, maple syrup, and vanilla extract until smooth.

2. Freeze –

• If you’re using the Ninja Creami, pour the mixture into a pint container and freeze for at least 8 hours.
• For the classic method, pour it into a loaf pan, cover tightly, and freeze overnight.

3. Spin or Scoop –

• With the Creami: Spin on the “Ice Cream” setting and it’s ready to serve!
• Without a Creami: Let the ice cream thaw slightly, break it up with a spoon, and then scoop.

4. Add Toppings – Serve it as or add your favorite toppings (fresh berries, chopped nuts, mini chocolate chips…you name it!).

Tips

• Freeze Overnight – Give it at least 8 hours in the freezer for the best texture!
• Let It Soften – If you’re not using a Ninja Creami, don’t forget to let the ice cream thaw for 15–20 minutes before scooping. Breaking it up with a spoon before scooping helps as well!
• Toppings – Crushed graham crackers, fruit, honey drizzle, peanut butter, or dark chocolate chips all take this to the next level.
• Split Into Servings – I like to freeze this recipe in two smaller containers so I can spin one at a time. It makes portioning easier and keeps the texture just right!

Healthy Ice Cream Recipe Variations

• Greek Yogurt Ice Cream Bars – Pour the mixture into silicone popsicle molds, freeze overnight, and you’ve got high-protein ice cream bars that are perfect for summer!
• Banana Yogurt Ice Cream – Blend 1–2 ripe bananas with the yogurt, maple syrup, and vanilla before freezing. The banana adds natural sweetness and makes it even creamier!
• Coconut Yogurt Ice Cream – Use full-fat coconut milk yogurt in place of Greek yogurt for a dairy-free option. Add shredded coconut or a swirl of pineapple puree for a tropical twist!

You’ll Also Love: Protein Ice Cream Recipe (Ninja Creami)

How to Store Homemade Frozen Yogurt

Freezer – Store in an airtight container for up to 1 month. If using a loaf pan, be sure to cover tightly with plastic wrap or an airtight lid to prevent freezer burn (I love using these ice cream containers (opens in a new tab) for best results!).

Before Serving – Let thaw for 15–20 minutes if you’re scooping without a Ninja Creami.

For Ninja Creami – Freeze in pint containers (opens in a new tab) and spin when ready. I like to keep a few pre-made pints in the freezer for quick desserts on busy nights!

Frozen Greek Yogurt FAQs

More Healthy Ice Cream Recipes

• Pistachio Cottage Cheese Ice Cream
• Healthy Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream
• Cookie Dough Ice Cream
• Brownie Batter Ice Cream
• Strawberry Cottage Cheese Ice Cream

Save This Recipe

Enter your email address and we'll send it straight to your inbox.

Website

First Name

Your Email

Plus new healthy recipes every week.

Save